Skip to main content
A Discussion
Circle of Pontormo
/

Two men, in robes of icy blue and pink, are engaged in a heated discussion, their expressive hands emphasising their strenuously argued points. They are watched by two bearded men; another, in green, looks at the bare wall in the background.

The subject of the painting is unclear. It was once identified as Herod questioning the Three Kings, but none of the figures is shown with a king’s crown or sceptre and there is no other evidence to suggest who they might be. The painting is more likely to show saints or prophets in debate, which was a popular motif in Florentine art during the early sixteenth century.

With its cool bright colours, expansive drapery and exaggerated dynamic poses, the painting is typical of the style of the Florentine Mannerist artist Pontormo. However, the figures are stiffer and more flatly modelled than those in Pontormo’s pictures, suggesting that it was probably not painted by Pontormo himself but by a close follower.

Key facts
Artist Circle of Pontormo
Artist dates 1494 - 1556/7
Full title A Discussion
Date made probably mid-1520s
Medium and support Oil on canvas transferred from wood
Dimensions 35.2 x 24.8 cm
Acquisition credit Mond Bequest, 1924
Inventory number NG3941
Location in Gallery Room 7
Download image
Download low-resolution image

Download an 800px wide, 72dpi copy of this image.

License this image

License and download a high resolution image for reproductions up to A3 size from the National Gallery Picture Library.

License image
Download low resolution image

This image is licensed for non-commercial use under a Creative Commons agreement.

Examples of non-commercial use are:

  • Research, private study, or for internal circulation within an educational organisation (such as a school, college or university)
  • Non-profit publications, personal websites, blogs, and social media

The image file is 800 pixels on the longest side.

As a charity, we depend upon the generosity of individuals to ensure the collection continues to engage and inspire. Help keep us free by making a donation today.

Yes, I'd like to donate
Or
Download low resolution image

You must agree to the Creative Commons terms and conditions to download this image.

Creative Commons Logo