Entering the Picture

Author: Amanda Lillie

2. Painted boundaries, thresholds and inner frames

Immediately inside the frame, artists often created their own painted borders as if they could not risk leaving the important task of delimitation and definition to a carpenter, sculptor, or frame specialist. Yet it was not only a question of establishing exact boundaries for the painted field, and a close look reveals that many artists were developing a more complex notion of the painting’s borders.3

Carlo Crivelli: Detail from 'The Annunciation, with Saint Emidius'.


Domenico Veneziano’s Saint Zenobius predella panel incorporates an illusionistic inner frame, painted in dark pink or carmine along the top and the right-hand side to suggest its depth and cast shadow, while paler pink is used to register the fall of light along the bottom of the picture (fig. 4). This creates a window effect for the image, as though we are looking through this frame to the narrative beyond, a technique recommended by Alberti in his treatise ‘De pictura’.4 This painted frame also unifies the panel with the rest of the predella and allocates it to a specific position within the overall framework of the altarpiece by means of its perspectival shadows.5 Even a simple inner frame like this reveals how precisely Domenico Veneziano was planning the work in relation to the viewing process.
 

Domenico Veneziano: 'A Miracle of Saint Zenobius'.
4. Domenico Veneziano, 'A Miracle of Saint Zenobius', about 1442–8, Fitzwilliam Museum, Cambridge. © Fitzwilliam Museum, Cambridge.

 

The illusionistic pavement edges, steps and sills at the base of paintings provide strong visual evidence that painters were interested in creating the idea of a picture that could be imaginatively entered and occupied. These ledges were probably intended as pointed messages placed low down in the extreme foreground, the area that is most easily approached and closely examined by spectators.

In ‘San Bernardino Preaching’ the edge of the pavement is displayed as though it were a block of paving set up in front of us, with its pavers and white stone dividers shown end on (figs. 5 and 6).6 Whether this was painted by Vecchietta, Francesco di Giorgio, or by another member of their Siena workshop, the artist is likely to have been inspired by a series of predecessors, such as the stepped end of the perspectival pavement in Ambrogio Lorenzetti’s ‘Presentation and Circumcision of Christ’ (1342) from the crossing of Siena Cathedral, or  Donatello’s bronze relief of the ‘Feast of Herod’ for Siena Baptistery (1427), where the edge of the diamond squared floor is folded 90 degrees to form a vertical edge for the panel.7

Studio of Lorenzo Vecchietta, possibly Francesco di Giorgio: 'Saint Bernardino Preaching'.
5. Studio of Lorenzo Vecchietta, possibly Francesco di Giorgio, 'Saint Bernardino Preaching', 1462–3, Walker Art Gallery, Liverpool. © Walker Art Gallery, National Museums Liverpool/The Bridgeman Art Library.

 

Studio of Lorenzo Vecchietta, possibly Francesco di Giorgio: Detail showing the edge of the pavement from 'Saint Bernardino Preaching'.
6. Detail of 'Saint Bernardino Preaching' showing the edge of the pavement.

 

In Costa and Maineri’s altarpiece the same device is employed with the base of its pavement seen so as to display the thickness of the marble (fig. 7). The pavement is no longer flat but has depth. Above all, this emphasises the low viewpoint so that worshippers feel they are looking up at a steeper angle, striving to see the holy figures of the Virgin, Christ Child and saints.8 

Lorenzo Costa and Gianfrancesco Maineri: Detail from 'The Virgin and Child with Saints'.
7. Detail of Lorenzo Costa and Gianfrancesco Maineri, 'The Virgin and Child with Saints', probably 1499, NG1119.

 

The pavement edges give out contradictory messages, setting up pictorial illusions while at the same time denying them. These thresholds partly function as doorsteps to invite the viewer in, helping to create the idea of a picture that can be entered. It could hardly be said that they create any sort of barrier, but they do set up a discreet notional separation between the painting and the outer world. Furthermore, they show the thickness and three-dimensional nature of the paving stones as though they were real objects.9 Painters and sculptors showed their architectural sensibilities in their handling of the pavement edge – meditating on the mass and materiality of the pavement. Despite these demonstrations, their edges proclaim the theatrical and fictional nature of the pavement as a delimited stage rather than as continuous space. This is very different and yet complementary to their perspectival construction of deep space. It shows a particular concern for the image as a vertically displayed object, and for perpendicular elevations within the work to balance the other dimensions of horizontality and depth.

Gerolamo da Vicenza: 'The Dormition and Assumption of the Virgin'.
8. Gerolamo da Vicenza, 'The Dormition and Assumption of the Virgin', 1488, NG3077.

 

In Gerolamo da Vicenza’s ‘Dormition and Assumption of Virgin’ (fig. 8), a succession of entry points is set up by the painter, wittily addressing the spectator on the threshold. This is another case of the artist going beyond the remit of the frame maker. The base of the picture is painted with an illusionistic moulded plinth of dark red marble, establishing the fiction of what we are looking at by declaring itself to be a framed painting. Breaking through this strip of pretend frame, up and over the plinth-like moulding, a white marble step extends out towards the spectator, providing a bridge to enable entry into the sacred zone of the picture. This seems playfully contrary, a form of visual teasing. The artist has first painted a fictive frame to separate the image from our world and then built a fictive bridge across it as though that were necessary to connect us with the world of the image. The next threshold at the front of the picture is an entrance like those to a chancel or a church choir with a marble balustrade and a half-open gate. Above the step is a holier place peopled with saints – symbolically distanced from our world. An alter ego is provided for us, like Alberti’s mediating chorus figure, in the person of a man in black kneeling on the very threshold, strategically positioned half in and half out of the sacred zone.

The set up partly resembles Filippino Lippi’s drawing of Thomas Aquinas [External link] – a study for the fresco in the Carafa Chapel in Santa Maria sopra Minerva, Rome – which includes a set of steps leading purposefully up into the scene.  But what is remarkable in Gerolamo da Vicenza's painting is how techniques used to create the theatrical illusionism in large-scale frescoed scenes with nearly life-size figures in churches could be applied to small-scale pictures, presumably for domestic use. The same type of stage setting and visual entry strategies apply.

Read further sections in this essay

To cite this essay we suggest using
Amanda Lillie, 'Entering the Picture' published online 2014, in 'Building the Picture: Architecture in Italian Renaissance Painting', The National Gallery, London, http://www.nationalgallery.org.uk/paintings/research/exhibition-catalogues/building-the-picture/entering-the-picture/painted-boundaries

 

For full details of the publications see Further Reading
3. Holmes 2013, pp. 207, 213–8; Duro 1996.                                                                                                                                                                 

4. Alberti 1972, Book I, p. 55, para. 19.

5. Wohl 1980, cat 9, pp. 131–2.

6. London 2007–8, cat 8, pp. 92–101.

7. This also applies to the squared pavement edges of Ghiberti’s ‘Isaac’ and ‘Joseph’ panels on the Gates of Paradise (completed 1437–9).

8. For later developments of this motif see Serlio 1996, Book II, ‘On Perspective’, fols 31v–35r (21v–24r), pp. 43–7, 70, and particularly his stage scenery, fols 67r –70v (45v–47v ) pp. 86–91.

9. In real cities the thickness of paving is rarely visible, since even at the edge of pavements, kerb stones cover and disguise the actual depth of stone. For artists, the rustic or landscape alternative to these urban models was to depict a small cliff along the bottom of the picture, another distancing device which seems to prevent our mistaking the world of the picture for our own. Ghiberti employs these rocky foregrounds and cliffs for many of the Florence Baptistery reliefs, as does Bartolommeo di Giovanni in his Troy 'cassone' panels in the Fitzwilliam Museum.

  • Share